Puffy Mattress Vs Casper: Which Is Better

If you can’t decide who wins between Puffy mattress vs Casper, check the features of each mattress first. Then, we will talk about each brand’s overall construction. This article will also compare how they are set up, considering both are bed-in-a-box models. 

Are you also interested in where the Puffy mattress is made? You can give that article a separate read since it will be helpful for you to get to know this brand better. 

puffy mattress vs casper


Puffy Mattress Vs Casper Mattress




Available mattress models

Puffy has three mattress models available, which are memory foam and latex beds. They are the Puffy mattress, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal. The Puffy Lux is the most popular of the three, and the Puffy Royal is what the brand considers as their premium mattress.


Trial, warranty, and returns

You can learn more about how to return a Puffy mattress in our separate article, but to give you a quick idea, you have a 101-night trial with every mattress. You can also enjoy Puffy’s lifetime warranty as long as you ensure that you got a genuine Puffy mattress. And if you indeed happened to return a bed, Puffy won’t resell or throw it away, but instead, work with charities, so those in need can use it. 


Flagship mattress

The flagship model of Puffy is the Puffy mattress, and it stands out from other foam beds because of its 5-layer structure. It is also compatible with all sleeping positions, and it is rated medium-firm to provide a balance between support and pressure relief. As for the popular hybrid, Puffy Lux, the coil system helps with back support and overall stability. 




Available mattress models

Casper is one of the best online mattress brands, and you can select from the Original, Element, Wave Hybrid, and Nova Hybrid models. All of them are available in standard six sizes, and the two Hybrid mattresses have a variant called the Hybrid Snow. This option allows the buyer to enjoy Casper’s Snow Technology for the ultimate cooling sleeping experience. 


Trial, warranty, and returns

You have a 100-night trial with a Casper mattress, and like Puffy, the brand requires you to use it for at least 30 days before considering returning it. The excellent news is returning is hassle-free since you can just pack the mattress with the label and then drop it off at any UPS location. And as for the warranty, Casper has a 10-year limited warranty with their beds for your peace of mind. 


Flagship mattress

The Casper Original is the brand’s flagship and ever-popular mattress. It is a cooling foam bed that features three zones of targeted support. You can even get the Casper Original as a hybrid if you prefer some bounciness on your bed. 


What Is Better The Casper Or The Puffy Mattress?

Both the Casper and the Puffy mattress are worth getting, especially if you want a bed-in-a-box model. But since every sleeper is different, see their noteworthy features and consider your preferences and needs. If you’re also interested in another bed-on-a-box mattress, we have a comparison review between Puffy vs Layla mattresses that you can check out. 


Casper Original mattress

  • Available in foam and hybrid versions
  • Uses CertiPUR-US-certified polyurethane and memory foams
  • Breathable foam layer
  • Zoned support to keep the spine neutral
  • The base is designed not to sag, but you can also read the expected lifespan of a Casper mattress in our separate review

Puffy mattress

  • Compatible with any base or surface
  • Uses a hypoallergenic and stain-resistant cover
  • Can be used for all sleeping positions
  • Cooling gel-foam layer 
  • Pressure-relieving core support

How Soon Can You Sleep On A Puffy Mattress?

Compared to other bed-in-a-box mattresses, Puffy is usable on the same day. You only need to let it expand for two hours before setting it up. More importantly, check if the base or foundation is the right size and not deformed.

How Soon Can You Sleep On A Casper Mattress?

Like the Puffy mattress, you don’t have to wait long before sleeping on a Casper mattress. After unboxing, you just need to cover it with sheets and place it right side up on the base. And if you’re also curious about what a Casper mattress is made of, read our in-depth analysis to know why it’s efficient at expanding. 

How To Setup Puffy Mattress

  1. Take out the rolled Puffy mattress and place it over the frame
  2. Remove the plastic cover, then unroll the bed
  3. Cut the remaining plastic seal and wait for it to expand after an hour or two

How To Setup Casper Mattress

  1. Place the Casper box over the frame, then slide out the rolled mattress
  2. Move the mattress in the proper position and remove the seal 
  3. Allow the Casper mattress to expand, which can take 24 hours, but it can be usable after an hour or two

Here is a more detailed guide on how to open a Casper mattress


Was this article helpful? To recap the review of Puffy mattress vs Casper mattress, choosing between them will depend on the sleeper. However, both are effective bed-in-a-box mattresses, so you won’t lose whichever you pick. 

If you need more help, don’t hesitate to leave us a question below. Of course, you can also check our articles about these brands.


Leave a Comment