Puffy Mattress Vs Tuft And Needle: Which Is Better

Choosing between the Puffy mattress vs Tuft and Needle mattress should be easy if you compare them. This article will go through each brand regarding the models available, policies, and even their signature or mattresses. We will also talk about their durability. 

Do you also happen to have a health condition that affects your sleep, such as arthritis or body pain? For example, try reading about the best Puffy mattress for neck and back pain with arthritis

puffy mattress vs tuft and needle


Puffy Mattress Vs Tuft And Needle Comparison Review


Puffy mattress


Available mattress models

Puffy has three mattress models composed of a foam bed and two hybrid beds. They are available in standard sizes, but not in split sizes. You can also check this separate article on where to buy a Puffy mattress near me if you’re curious whether the brand has stores or showrooms for seeing these beds in person. 


Trial, warranty, and returns

Puffy offers 101 nights for you to try their mattress, but you can consider returning it as early as after 30 nights if you’re unsatisfied. Learning how to return a Puffy mattress is relatively fast if it’s a genuine Puffy product. But perhaps the most significant advantage of a Puffy mattress compared to others is that the brand provides a lifetime warranty so that you can feel confident about it.


Flagship mattress

The flagship mattress of Puffy is the memory foam bed called the Puffy mattress. It is a medium-firm mattress that is compatible with all sleeping positions. As proven by the reviews on Puffy’s websites, buyers are satisfied with this model providing support for back pain and even comfort to help with insomnia. 


Tuft and Needle


Available mattress models

Tuft and Needle offer three mattresses similar to Puffy. They are the T & N Original, Mint, and Hybrid, all at reasonably affordable price points. The Original and Mint are also foam beds, while the Hybrid model is the brand’s only hybrid mattress. 


Trial, warranty, and returns

You’ll get a 100-night trial with the Tuft and Needle mattress. Similar to Puffy, Tuft and Needle won’t resell your returned bed, but instead, they’ll donate it to charity. And as for the Tuft and Needle mattress warranty, it covers ten years compared to the lifetime warranty of Puffy.


Flagship mattress

The T & N Original mattress is the brand’s flagship bed. It only costs $895 for a queen size, and you’ll get a 10-inch tall body-conforming foam bed. But because it is firmer, note that it is best for back and stomach sleepers compared to the Mint and Hybrid mattresses that can cushion side sleepers. 


Are Puffy Mattresses Too Hard?

Puffy mattresses are not too hard because they are designed for all sleeping positions. To give you a quick idea, the Puffy mattress is medium-firm, while you can get a slightly softer feel with the Puffy Lux that is medium-plush. They are rated 6 to 8 and 5 to 7 on the firmness scale, so they should be compatible with all sleepers. 

Please consider reading this article on what the Puffy mattress is because it talks about its overall construction and materials in more detail.


How Long Can You Keep The Puffy Mattress In The Box?

Since Puffy is a bed-in-a-box mattress, you can unbox it immediately after delivery. This will allow it to expand as soon as possible. But since it is made of memory foam, you can leave it in the box for a day or two if you can’t immediately unpack it. 

Learn more about how long you can leave a memory foam mattress in a box if you can’t unbox your newly delivered bed as quickly. 


How Long Does The Puffy Mattress Last?

Puffy mattresses can last for up to 10 years, depending on your use and maintenance. Remember that the brand provides a lifetime warranty, so they’re confident with its longevity. We have also discussed where Puffy mattresses are made if you’re curious. 


Are Tuft And Needle Mattresses Too Hard?

Tuft and Needle mattresses are not too hard, but the T & N Original mattress is firm enough to be ideal for stomach sleepers. On the other hand, if you want a plusher feel, you can get the Mint or Hybrid mattresses because they are also suitable for side sleepers. Nonetheless, do not worry about getting a very hard bed from Tuft and Needle, because even the Original model is compatible with back sleepers that need some cushioning to relieve pressure on the spine. 


How Long Can You Keep Tuft And Needle Mattress In The Box?

Tuft and Needle recommend that you must unbox their mattress as soon as possible. But if you can’t, you can leave it in the box for up to three weeks. Then, the expansion of the bed is as long as Puffy at about 2 hours. 


How Long Does The Tuft And Needle Mattress Last?

Tuft and Needle mattresses should last for 8 years or more as proven by their 10-year warranty. Furthermore, their mattresses use the brand’s unique Adaptive foam that is durable enough to prevent body impressions.  



And that’s it! We just reviewed Puffy mattress vs Tuft and Needle mattress, and the winner will depend on your priority features since they both offer excellent policies regarding returns and warranty. However, Puffy provides a more extended lifetime warranty than T & N’s 10-year warranty. 

And if you can’t unbox your delivered mattress immediately, consider getting from T & N instead since it can remain in the box for three weeks. 

Leave a Comment